The Colorado AnglerThe Colorado Angler
☰ Menu
  • Fishing Reports
  • Guide Service
    • Float Trips
    • Wade Trips
    • Trip Checklist
    • Our Guides
    • Guide School
  • The Shop
  • Blog
  • Book Now
970-513-8055

Archived Fishing Report for May 9th, 2020

Book A Trip Now
scroll down for more

Fishing Report for: May 9th, 2020

It is that time of year when we start to see spring snow melt having an impact on conditions. It may be slightly earlier than typical, but certainly not unexpected. This is part of the normal cycle and will have some effect on day-to-day results in many locations. However, it is not the end of all fishing, and as we are seeing this morning, after a couple of cooler days this week there is a momentary improvement to several popular access points.

There are still good hatches happening, with Caddis on the Arkansas, Roaring Fork, and Eagle along with Baetis and Midges still emerging just about everywhere. As well, with stream flows on the rise and clarity headed in the opposite direction,  streamer fishing is becoming a higher percentage endeavor.

The key to fishing at this time of year is a combination of doing a little pre departure preparation before heading to the river and then being flexible once you get there. With a little homework before you leave your house you can get an idea on what to expect before you get to the river, familiarize yourself with stream flow gauges and what they mean. Likewise, once you get to a spot don’t be too rigid in you approach to fishing it. Clarity may be off color or higher than you are accustom to, but typically speaking as long as you are not trying to fish it while it is climbing or as it is getting dirty, the fish will adjust to the change in conditions.  Don’t be resistant to trying flies or techniques that you don’t normally use under stable conditions, and be willing to try a different habitat character – such as the upstream current in a back eddy versus a riffle, or other water types that allow for sheltered lies for fish in heavier currents.

It is important to note during these times of stay-at-home orders, that vary by agency, to be aware of limitations for recreation in certain locations.  While there are no widespread closures, there are some counties that are prohibiting non-residents from visiting their counties for recreational purposes.  Including Clear Creek, Chaffee, Eagle, Summit and Gunnison to name a few.  Hopefully these will be short-term closures and non-residents can get back to fishing those destinations soon.  If you do reside in one of those counties, enjoy what should be some solitary conditions.

Another logistical consideration at the moment is going to be for float anglers.  As the current health crisis continues to impact our everyday lives, shuttles are no different.  On the upper river, Rancho is not yet running shuttles, as they are waiting for the curve to flatten.  While down in the Glenwood area there is a limitation to normal options, as ride sharing services have been reduced and there is concern about driving complete strangers vehicles and the potential for transmission of the virus.  We would say your safest bet is to handle your shuttle yourself.

Detailed reports below will give more specific information on a particular stretch of river.  Don’t hesitate to stop by or call us with any questions pertaining to flows, hatches or flies.

Detailed Reports - Click on a location for details.

Blue River Below Dillon Reservoir

Rating:

3 out of 5

Conditions

Big changes in town as the release from the dam is up in anticipation of spring runoff into the reservoir.This is good news any way you look at it.  The additional water will help spread out fish into greater habitat, as well, it will offer them added cover from predators, hopefully making them feel a little more at ease.  But even more important, the added flow from the dam creates a stronger pull of food from the reservoir, most notably in the form of Mysis Shrimp.

From a technical standpoint, the good news is that you can bump up your tippet size a notch, 5x should be light enough, maybe even 4x.  While you’re at it don’t overlook the need for extra weight, anywhere from 1 to 2 BBs for most spots.

In addition to the Mysis, Midges are still the primary aquatic insect in the food chain, with good results also coming on the typical “spring-water-is-on-the-rise” patterns. ie Spaghetti and Meatballs.

Traffic overall has been lighter than typical, but as the fishing has improved and we near the end of the tightest travel restrictions, we anticipate busier days lie ahead.

 

Flies

BTS Shrimp, Tim’s Mysis, Stalcup’s Mysis, Red Neck Midge, Glassy Brassie, Mirage Zebra Midge, Rainbow Warrior, Tube Midges, Black Beauty, Brassie, Bead Head Biot Midge, Tungsten Psycho May-Black, Rojo Midge, RS-2 – Black or Dun, WD40 – Black or Chocolate, Zebra Midge, Flossy Worm, Squirmy Wormy, Huevos, #20-#24 Pheasant Tail

Current Water Data

Blue River Below Green Mountain

Rating:

2.5 out of 5

Conditions

Although there was a short-lived bump up in the release from Green Mountain, flows remain very low for this popular tailwater and this is having an impact on action.  We generally find results to be stronger on overcast days, as well as the lower light times of day when there aren’t any clouds.  Definitely drop down to at least 5x, but 6x has been more productive with the clarity being completely transparent. Be careful getting down to and back up from the river. Slick conditions on the steep canyon walls makes for a treacherous hike, and torn waders or a broken rod is a real possibility.  A decent range of food options  due to a rich biomass, gives you the potential for results on Midges and Baetis along with Stonefly and searching nymphs.  Tandem nymph rigs drifted through the deeper runs have been the most consistent but keep an eye out for any early season emergence of those Midges and Baetis to potentially bring a few fish to the surface.

We have not had any communication with water managers at Green Mountain to see what their schedule for spring releases is. The lake is starting to fill, but it has a way to go at this point. With a fairly robust snow pack in the Blue River Valley we are anticipating a strong run-off which will require a spill.  That being the case, they tend to ramp up outflow ahead of time in anticipation of that spill, so that it doesn’t go from zero to apocalyptic overnight.

Flies

BH PT, Perdigon Nymph, Quill Body Jig in dark olive, Darth Baetis, Magic Fly BWO, Tungsten Psycho May,  Pat’s Rubberlegs, Psycho Prince, Duracell Jig, Poison Tung, Zebra Midge, Foam Wing RS-2, Flossy Worm, Parachute Extended Body BWO, CDC Baetis Dun, Slate Gray No Hackle, Winger Parachute, Parachute Purple, Sculpzilla, Sex Dungeon, Cheech Leech, Sparkle Minnow etc

Current Water Data

Colorado River Above Kremmling (Parshall)

Rating:

2 out of 5

Conditions

The stream flow at Parshall is actually in the 900cfs range, we are having trouble getting a link to the correct gauge below the confluence with the William’s Fork. Not as high as it has been this past week, but still a robust amount of water and will offer a limited range for wading/crossing the river. However, with the flow down from higher levels there should be some degree of clearing, offering a chance for success if you happen to be in the neighborhood.  There are still good opportunities for Midges, but Baetis hatches have become a consistent event, especially on days with afternoon clouds.

Nymph imitations for those two hatches fished in tandem with a mix of Stonefly and searching nymphs have been solid early.  Start the day focused on the tail out of runs and deeper lies where trout can shelter a bit out of the heavier currents.  As the day progresses and rising water temps spark insect activity, shift that focus towards the head of runs and bottoms of riffles where the fish should move to feed on drifting nymphs.

Flies

Pat’s Rubber Legs, Flashback Hare’s Ear, Miller’s Tactical + One, Flossy Worm, CDC Pheasant Tail, Bead Prince, Psycho Prince, Breadcrust,  Pheasant Tail #14-18 -beaded and not- Redemption BWO, Darth Baetis, Split Case BWO, Tungsten Micro Mayfly Brown, Tungsten Juju Baetis, Aero Baetis, Root Beer Float, Zebra midge in black, Bead Head Biot Midge, Sparkle Worm, Silver Bullet Minnow, Goldie, Heisenberg White, Mini Peanut Envy white, Sex Dungeon cream,  Sculpzilla

Current Water Data

Colorado River Pumphouse to Dotsero

Rating:

2.5 out of 5

Conditions

After a solid surge in water and dramatic drop in clarity last week, things have stabilized for the moment after a few cooler days. Although clarity if far from gin clear, it is enough for trout to feed with a little more enthusiasm than earlier in the week. Nymph rigs are the most consistent method, focused on a variety of large Stonefly imitations, beaded searching patterns, Caddis and Baetis variations. As well, streamer patterns continue to do well, particularly Sculpin imitations as their spawn is wrapping up.

The farther down you go the dirtier it is going to be. We would recommend starting above Radium where Sheephorn Creek runs into the main channel and adds a good deal of color. If that confluence doesn’t look too bad then the next big influence will be Piney Creek just above the State Bridge ramp.

And don’t forget, Rancho is not running shuttles. So make a plan before getting to the river.

Flies

GT Adult BWO, Slate Gray No Hackle, Winger Parachute, CDC Dun Baetis, Parachute Extended Body BWO, Pat’s Rubber Legs, Psycho Prince, Yeager’s Soft Hackle, Bead Head Pheasant Tail, Duracell, Aero Baetis, Millers Tactical Plus 1, Magic Fly, Foam Wing RS2, Tungsten Psycho May, Darth Baetis, Zebra midges, Sculpzilla, Silver Bullet, Sex Dungeon,

Current Water Data

Colorado River Below Glenwood Springs

Rating:

3.5 out of 5

Conditions

After the warm up things are pretty well shot on the lower river, as clarity has cratered. It is currently running various shades of brown, from light mocha to full on chocolate. Once run-off peaks, starts to stabilize and then drop, look for the color to switch over to a greenish tint before committing to this stretch again.

Keep in mind that the boat ramp at Two Rivers Park in Glenwood remains closed for a remodel, so plan on using other access points.

Flies

Pat’s Rubber Legs, Tungteaser, CDC BH Pheasant Tail, Bead Prince, Duracell Jig, Tungsten Pheasant Tail, Bead Hares Ear, Yeager’s BH Soft Hackle J, Zebra Midges, San Juan Worm patterns, Flossy Worm, Sex Dungeon, Heisenberg Streamers, Sculpzilla, Silver Bullet.

Current Water Data

Arkansas River Above Buena Vista

Rating:

3 out of 5

Conditions

Action is really heating up along the upper stretch of the river. Strong hatches of Midges and Blue Winged Olives can be found from Buena Vista up to Leadville, with lesser amounts of Caddis starting to show up in the BV area. Clarity remains decent in the upper basin, even as flows have bumped substantially from Twin Lakes in anticipation of spring snow melt. Even still the volume allows for good wade access and should help to put trout at ease as it offers more cover. Early in the day, before the hatch starts, tandem nymph rigs should be the most consistent.  Lead with a mid to larger Stonefly or beaded searching nymph, followed up with either a Baetis or Midge imitation.  There have also been days when Caddis larva have been productive.  Keep a watch for emerging bugs in the afternoon, as the opportunity to find rising fish is getting more consistent every day.  Although temperatures in the upper basin are still a bit cooler than downstream, the streamer action is starting to pick up.  Make sure to experiment with retrieval patterns and speed, as the fish may not be as aggressive in their pursuit of larger prey.

Flies

Brooks Sprout Baetis, No Hackle Slate Gray, Pat’s Rubber Legs, Miller’s Tactical Plus One, Red Collar Leggy PT, Duracell, Copper John, BH Pheasant Tail, BH Hare’s Ear, Lil Spanker, Hot Wire Prince, Psycho Prince, Yeager’s Soft Hackle J, Iron Sally, Perdigon, Tungsten Psycho May, Tungsten Micro Mayfly, Beaded Biot Midge, Flossy Worm, Silver Bullet

Current Water Data

Arkansas River Salida Area

Rating:

3.5 out of 5

Conditions

Conditions in the Salida area have been spotty over the last couple of weeks with the warm weather initially driving an early start to run-off. However, with a brief interruption in that heat, we have seen a little improvement to clarity, although flows continue to climb as upstream releases from Twin Lakes have steadily increased in anticipation of additional snow melt.  This will begin to impact wading access in spots, with regards to comfort and stability, but will in no way prevent continued success on foot.  At the same time these are great levels for floating and will allow for the anglers to focus on the edge water with dries and streamers.

Unfortunately, unless you are a resident of Chaffee county, you can’t actually fish in Chaffeee County at the moment, as the county has closed all recreation to non-county residents due to the current health crisis.

On the other hand, if you are a resident enjoy a combination of uncrowded waters and a growing emergence of Caddis.  In particular on sunny days when water temps climb high enough to spark a late day hatch. On those days when clouds dominate, expect to see a greater amount of Baetis, which are still a major influence at this time of year.

We recommend starting with a beaded Stonefly or searching nymph, like a Pheasant Tail or Hare’s Ear and following that up with either Baetis or Caddis imitations.

Flies

Elk Hair Caddis, Ginger Caddis, Foam Caddis, Spotlight Caddis, Para Extended Body BWO, GT Adult BWO, No Hackle Slate Gray, Pat’s Rubber Legs, Red Collar Leggy PT, Duracell, Copper John, BH Pheasant Tail, Psycho Prince, Yeager’s Soft Hackle J, GB Biot Epoxy Stone, Matt Demon Stone, Iron Sally, Tungsten Psycho May, Tungsten Micro Mayfly, Beaded Biot Midge, Zebra Midge, Poison Tung, Flossy Worm, Purple parachutes, Winger Parachute, Silver Bullet, Sparkle Minnow.

Current Water Data

Roaring Fork River at Glenwood Springs

Rating:

3 out of 5

Conditions

After an initial spike in flows to start the month, there has been a slight retreat in volume and a good improvement in clarity, particularly in the upper valley above the Crystal. Caddis continue to emerge, as well as Baetis the higher up you go. This is a short reprieve so enjoy it while you can. Good flows for both wading and floating anglers. The action early in the day will be more consistent nymphing, as water temps take some time to warm enough to kick off the bugs. Big Stonefly imitations or beaded searching nymphs followed up with a Baetis pattern or Caddis pupa.  By early to mid-afternoon look for adults to start emerging and intensifying later in the day.  Once that happens, make the switch over to dries and fish the edge water, riffles and pockets.

Keep in mind that the Two Rivers boat ramp in Glenwood Springs is still closed for a construction project, so if you are floating the lower river make sure to familiarize yourself with alternative take-outs.

Flies

BH Pheasant Tail, BH Prince, Duracell Jig, Chartreuse Copper John, Yeager’s Soft Hackle J,Foam Wing RS-2, Tungsten Psycho May, Darth Baetis, Flashwing RS-2, Split Case BWO, Pat’s RL, San Juan Worm, Pat’s Rubber legs, Peacock Caddis, Mother’s Day Caddis, Elk Hair Caddis, Chubby Chernobyl, Body Double Caddis

Current Water Data

Williams Fork River Below Dam

Rating:

2.5 out of 5

Conditions

Flows are holding steady and the river is running at a solid early season flow.   This flow should provide good enough cover for fish to spread out a bit from their winter “low water” lies and offer more opportunities for anglers. As well, this should be a good level to take advantage of the reconditioned channel from the recent restoration project that was completed just last fall.  There will still be sections that haven’t seen the insect population completely back fill yet, but that will improve as the season goes on.  As you would expect, Midges are key right now but Baetis, smaller Stonefly nymphs and Caddis imitations can be productive as part of a two nymph set-up. (The Breadcrust is an all time pattern for a point fly)

Flies

Darth Baetis, Breadcrust, Duracell Jig, Perdigon Nymphs, Poison Tung, 5-0 Midge, Pure Midge Larva, Flashback Pheasant Tail, RS-2, Foam Wing RS-2, Buckskin, Tungsten Psycho Mayfly, Barr’s Emerger, Miller’s Tactical Plus One

Current Water Data

Eagle River

Rating:

3.5 out of 5

Conditions

Action continues to be solid up and down the river, depending on the day.  With warmer temps over the first couple of weeks of the month, we are seeing low elevation snow melt having an impact on conditions at times.  In particular, as you work down stream from Wolcott and pick up sedimentary laden tributaries from the North.

With a shot of cold temperatures the past week that has helped to slow that and offer a greater amount of fish-able water. In your search for clean water it is important to keep in mind a couple of things for fishing the Eagle.  First, this is a river that does have a tendency to run a little off color for long periods of time, and as such the resident fish don’t mind a little bit of tint to the water. As long as it isn’t in the process of turning from clear to dirty and you have a foot or better, you should still give it a shot. And the second tip would be to not assume it is dirtier downstream.  Yes, that can be the case, but at this time of year as it warms and cools most days there will be waves of off-color water that move through.  Sometimes it is possible to head downstream and get in front of that wave of dirty water, at least for a couple of hours before it catches you.

When you do find that good water, there have been a wide assortment of patterns working.  Start with Baetis and Midges, add in Stonefly and beaded searching patterns, with some people reporting the spaghetti and meatball rigs to be effective, as well. Particularly when you find that off-color water. As well, there are pockets of Caddis starting to move up river.

Flies

Duracell Jig, Tungsten Psycho May, RS-2, Juju Baetis, Darth Baetis, Aero Baetis, Perdigon Nymph, Miller’s Tactical Plus one, Pat’s Rubber Legs, Psycho Prince, Bead Head Pheasant Tail, Yeager’s Soft Hackle J, Sparkle Worm, Flossy Worm,Glister Grub, Huevos

Current Water Data
  • < Next Report
  • Previous Report >

Our Location

Contact Us

Phone Icon 970-513-8055

Email Icon [email protected]


Fly Shop Address

249 Summit Place,
Silverthorne, CO 80498

Fly Shop Hours:

Monday-Thursday: 7:00am – 6:30pm
Friday, Saturday: 7:00am – 7pm
Sunday: 7:00am-5:30pm

© 2025 The Colorado Angler |  Sitemap
Website by Best Colorado Web Design

Connect With Us:trip advisor icon facebook icon instagram icontrip advisor icon